The final internet screen – television

Whilst being one of the oldest screens in our lives the television set has remained for most of us a fairly passive medium, one where we sit back and watch in true, cool Marshall McLuhan style. But not for much longer if Google and Project Canvas have their way.

[picapp align=”none” wrap=”false” link=”term=television+lounge&iid=179263″ src=”0175/8c2b58cd-c048-49e3-900e-7acb6ec78918.jpg?adImageId=12958177&imageId=179263″ width=”413″ height=”413″ /]
There have been a few attempts to change how televisions can be used. Back in the late 70s and 80s we had Ceefax and Teletext – some of you may even remember pressing the “Reveal” button to gain answers to quiz questions. When digital television came along such services developed into the “Red Button”, where text data and additional programme channels could be found. None of which is/was internet enabled, by the way.

There have been attempts to integrate the internet with the television for but for the most part the interactive benefits of the web have yet to really come to a lounge near you.

The reasons for this are numerous, but one of the big challenges (or even battles) has been over standards – in particular how broadcasters pipe data to ‘televisions’ and set-top boxes.

In parallel to these developments, games console manufacturers (significant as they are plugged into the television set) have successfully developed web-enabled boxes, which have now been in use for several years. This has meant not only that games can be played across the web in real-time with players across the world, but also that YouTube videos and the BBC’s iPlayer can be viewed via the television screen. Sky has taken the logical next step and partnered with Microsoft to create an online television service for XBox owners.

Yet, these services are still quite niche and rather limited. Enter Google and the BBC.

This week Google launched Google TV. A service they describe as, “a new experience made for television that combines the TV you know and love with the freedom and power of the Internet.” Here’s a video that explains more:

But before you get too excited… it needs to be made clear that Google TV is a platform. Its an answer to the standards problem mentioned above, so the purchase of either a new television or set-top-box will be required. Google has worked with Sony (TV manufactures), Logitech (set-top-box makers) and Intel (someone has to make the microchip for all this stuff to work efficiently).

“So hurrah, Google has sorted the standards problem out, go them!”
Not so fast. Also this week the Office for Fair Trading (OFT) announced that the BBC’s Project Canvas fell outside it’s ‘merger control jusitiction’.

Ok, so, ummm, what does that mean in reality?

Project Canvas is a proposed joint venture between the BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Five, BT, Talk Talk and Arqiva in creating “an open internet-connected television platform with common technical standards”.

For those unfamiliar with Arqiva, they are a “communications infrastructure and media services company”, who provide the infrastructure behind digital tv and radio in the UK and Ireland as well as other European countries.

The reason that the OFT had got involved is due to complaints by BSkyB and Virgin media on grounds that it created unfair advantage, explained here by the Guardian:

BSkyB has argued that Project Canvas, and particularly its backing by the licence fee-funded BBC, amounts to giving its rivals an unfair leg up in the nascent UK VoD market. Virgin Media has argued that despite its protestations to the contrary Project Canvas, which will bring VoD content to TV viewers with Freeview and Freesat receivers, is an unfair closed platform.

The intent of Project Canvas is that:

a consumer brand (not canvas) will be created, and licensed to device manufacturers, and internet service providers owners who meet the specifications.
‘Canvas compliant’ devices (eg set-top boxes), built to a common technical standard, would provide seamless access to a range of third-party services through a common, simple, user experience. [more here].

Project Canvas now awaits final approval by the BBC Trust, but it is now very likely it will get the go-ahead. Project Canvas will be like the BBC’s previous free-to-air brands such as Freeview and Freesat, which transformed take-up of digital television in the UK. What will be interesting to watch is if the same happens again or whether the likes of Google TV (or others) will win through on existing brand familiarity. To do so Google, in the UK at least, will very likely have it’s work cut out, should Project Canvas get the go-ahead.

Either way, TV as we know it is changing.

UPDATE [18.49]: And in related news today…
BBC iPlayer is going social with version 3.0 Beta.
The Times gives a few more details reporting that:

THE BBC will forge closer links with social networking firms this week when it unveils a new version of its catch-up television service iPlayer that integrates with Facebook and Twitter.

Moving beyond personalisation

Back page of 8
Back page of 8
A few months ago I was commissioned by the BBC’s Knowledge Exchange Programme (KEP) – a collaboration between BBC R&D and the Arts & Humanities Research Council – to write an essay looking at the personalisation of media in response to the eight year-long academic studies that had been produced for the programme.

The research studies covered the the breadth of the BBC’s digital output from it’s newsrooms and communities around radio programmes through to online-only content such as Adventure Rock – a 3D online world for children. The titles of the research papers are as follows:

* UGC at the BBC
* Alone Together? Social Learning in BBC Blast
* A Public Voice – Access, Digital Story and Interactive Narrative
* Children in Virtual Worlds
* Virtual Worlds – An Overview and Study of BBC Children’s Adventure Rock
* Inhibited Exploration in Older Customers of Digital Services
* Listener Online Engagement with BBC Radio Programming
* Radio listeners online – A case study of The Archers
* The Miners’ Strike – A Case Study in Regional Content

NOTE: Background to the papers and a list of links to the papers can be read and downloaded here.

What struck me reading the papers and using the BBC’s digital services was that a lot of time was being spent in moderating services and encouraging viewers to have their say without necessarily taking things further. That whilst the BBC had successfully used many digital tools to engage audiences there were structures that could be put in place to enhance those relationships and also enable the organisation to focus it’s time and attention more efficiently.

Expectations and digital literacy of users have also dramatically increased as online experiences have become more sophisiticated. Interactivity is not just about personalising any more, it’s about participation, remixing, collaborating. ie. How can the BBC engage the new active audience in relationships that work for everyone?

In the essay I examine a number of strategies (including some based on the experiences we had with the Digital Britain Unconferences) and structures that are relevant not just to the BBC but to many other organisations who wish to engage with online audiences more deeply – large or small, small or large budgets.

The final essay can be read in PDF format here (page 17) together with seven other essays by the likes of Bill Thompson and Pat Kane. Paper copies (slightly easier to read) may be available if you ask the Knowledge Exchange Team nicely.

More background to the 8 collection of essays can be read here.
Beyond personal

BBC Innovation Labs 2007

This article originally appeared in March 2007 in NMK, whose server was damaged in a fire last year.


The BBC Innovation Labs have been much heralded by NMK, but what do we actually know about what happens if you’re lucky enough to go and what happens if your idea gets chosen? Kathryn Corrick spent time at the London Labs and spoke to Paola Kathuria and Frank Wales of Limitless Innovations to find out more.

Continue reading → BBC Innovation Labs 2007